Has your planning permission been refused? A refusal does not end your project. We explain how we read the grounds for refusal, choose between an appeal and a new application, rework the plans and resume dialogue with the authorities.
The letter from the municipality has arrived, and the decision is a refusal. For a private individual, this is often a shock. For an investor, it means a schedule slipping. At STARC, however, we regularly see refused projects go on to obtain their permit, because a reasoned refusal often indicates fairly precisely what needs to change.
Reading the refusal as a brief
A refusal decision is not a simple no. It rests on grounds, opinions and sometimes objections lodged during the public inquiry. Before deciding anything, we read the entire file and sort each ground into one of these categories:
- Substantive grounds: the project departs from a planning guide, a municipal scheme or the built character of the neighbourhood.
- Grounds linked to scale: height, depth, footprint, a volume judged too massive compared to neighbouring houses.
- Grounds linked to neighbours: direct views, loss of sunlight, privacy of gardens.
- Grounds linked to appearance: materials, colours, roof pitch, rhythm of openings.
- Procedural grounds: a missing document, an imprecise plan, an opinion from a department that was not consulted.
This classification changes everything. An incomplete file, or a project refused because it exceeds the height limit by 80 cm, is not handled the same way as a project that contradicts the zoning of the area. In the first case, a few design adjustments are often enough. In the second, the brief needs rethinking.
Three possible paths after a refusal
In Wallonia, the applicant has access to an administrative appeal. According to the Service public de Wallonie (the Walloon public service), it must be lodged within 30 days of receiving the contested decision, using a form (annex 20 of the CoDT, the Walloon Territorial Development Code). The Walloon Government then reviews the whole file again. In practice, we have three options.
- An appeal to the Walloon Government, with the project as submitted, when we believe the refusal is not well founded.
- An appeal accompanied by amended plans. Since the CoDT reform, this is possible against a decision of the local council, but under strict conditions: according to the Union des Villes et Communes de Wallonie (the Walloon union of towns and municipalities), these plans may only have a limited scope and must be grounded in an observation raised during the public inquiry, in an opinion, or in the decision itself.
- A new planning application, based on a more thoroughly reworked project. This can be preceded by a certificat d'urbanisme n°2 (a stage-two planning certificate), which allows the main options to be checked before resubmitting: before reintroducing an application after a refusal, it can be worthwhile to request a certificat d'urbanisme n°2 (CU2).
An appeal to the Conseil d'État (Council of State) remains possible as a last resort, but it does not re-examine the design itself: if the administrative appeal is rejected, a final level opens before the Council of State, which rules solely on the legality of the decision.
In Brussels, the logic is similar: the applicant can lodge an appeal with the Brussels Government within 30 days of notification of the contested decision, and an opinion is issued by the Collège d'urbanisme (Urban Planning Board).
What we do in the first few days
Thirty days pass quickly. Our method follows a few steps.
- Day 1 to 3: reading the decision and all opinions, listing the objections, checking receipt dates to fix the exact deadline.
- Day 3 to 7: a meeting with you. We discuss the project, but also your budget, your schedule and what cannot be sacrificed (a ground floor bedroom, a certain number of units, a view onto the garden).
- Day 7 to 15: sketching alternatives. We test two or three responses to the main ground, using a digital model, with the actual shadow cast on neighbouring plots.
- Day 15 to 25: choosing the path, drafting the arguments, finalising the plans.
- Before day 30: lodging the appeal or, if we opt for a new application, getting in touch with the planning department.
When the building already exists, an accurate 3D scan survey, carried out with our partners at Optibim, avoids disputes over dimensions. An accurate plan reassures the authority.
Adjusting the plans without betraying the project
This is where the craft of architecture really comes into its own. It is not about trimming the project until it loses its interest, but about finding the change that addresses the ground while preserving what matters most. A few examples from our practice:
- A volume judged too tall: we lower the cornice and fit part of the brief under a pitched slate roof. The living area stays almost the same.
- An extension depriving the neighbour of light: we shift it a metre and replace the blind party wall with a set-back volume. The impact on your living room is minor, the impact on the neighbour's garden is real.
- A contemporary façade judged out of place in a street of blue stone and brick: we keep the current design language, but match the local brick colour, the alignment of openings and the rhythm of the plots.
- An apartment building refused for its density: we rework the typology, with fewer small units and more large ones, without undermining the financial balance of the scheme.
For an investor or developer, we cost each option in saleable area and expense. The decision then becomes as much economic as architectural.
Preparing the hearing and reopening dialogue with the authority
In Wallonia, the appeal leads to a hearing. Under the CoDT, the Government invites the applicant, the local council, the regional planning officer, the administration and the appeals advisory board to attend, within forty-five days of receiving the appeal. The administration then sends the Government a draft decision within 65 days of receiving the appeal, and the Government rules within the deadlines set by the Code.
We prepare for this hearing as we would a project presentation: a few clear boards, views in context, sections showing the relationship to neighbours, a point-by-point response to the grounds. We attend with you. Tone matters. The authority is not an opponent, and a constructive exchange often reveals a path towards agreement.
If we opt for a new application, we request a meeting with the planning department or the regional planning officer before submitting. Presenting a sketch and listening to the comments costs a morning and can save months.
Pitfalls to avoid
- Letting the 30-day deadline pass while hoping for an informal arrangement.
- Challenging a refusal based on a clear rule without changing the project.
- Resubmitting the same file with only a few details altered.
- Ignoring neighbours' objections: they will come back at the next public inquiry.
- Starting works or signing with a contractor before holding a final permit.
Has your permit been refused, or are you worried it might be? Send us the decision and your plans. We will read them with you, tell you honestly which path seems most solid and what it means for your project, in Wallonia as in Brussels. Our Gembloux office welcomes you by appointment.
Frédéric Odent, director of STARC
